Skip to content
Mentavo

Impostor Feelings: When Success Starts to Look Like a Misunderstanding

The core isn't insecurity but a very particular way of assigning causes — and that can be described far more precisely than the label suggests.

6 min read

an empty wooden lectern on a small stage in an empty lecture hall, lit by a single soft overhead light

The promotion has gone through. The feedback was good. Someone says you really handled that well.

And the first thought isn't “thank you”.

“They just don't know yet.”

What's odd about this isn't the doubt itself. Doubt is warranted in plenty of places.

What's odd is that the evidence against it achieves nothing. The more of it accumulates, the more the whole thing looks like a run of lucky circumstances.

What this means — and what it doesn't

The pattern was first described in the late 1970s, initially among successful women in academic careers. It later turned out not to be limited to that group at all.

One qualification is almost always missing in everyday use: this is not a recognised clinical diagnosis. There are no official criteria, no threshold above which someone “has it”.

That also explains why the figures in circulation diverge so wildly. A large systematic review pooling more than sixty individual studies with over 14,000 participants between them found prevalence rates ranging from nine to eighty-two per cent — depending on which questionnaire was used and where the cutoff was drawn.

When a figure swings between “rare exception” and “almost everyone” depending on the instrument, it says very little. The common claim that a specific percentage of people are affected therefore has no solid basis.

What does exist is a well-describable pattern. And that is more useful day to day than any number.

The core: an asymmetry in causes

The pattern can be pinned down fairly precisely. It is not about low self-confidence in general, but about a particular way of distributing causes.

When something works, it was the circumstances: favourable timing, a generous panel, good support, an easy task, luck.

When something fails, it was the person.

This asymmetry is the actual mechanism. It is notable because it inverts the usual bias: people normally tend to credit themselves with successes and blame circumstances for failures. Here it runs exactly the other way.

And it explains why evidence stays ineffective. Each new success gets re-sorted on arrival — away from your own contribution, towards the circumstances. The pile of counter-evidence grows without ever registering as evidence.

Why more success can intensify the feeling

Here is the part that surprises many people: the feeling often doesn't shrink as success accumulates. It grows.

The reason is simple. With every step up, the stakes rise. A new role means more visibility, more people expecting something, and a wider gap between what you have mastered and what you are supposed to have mastered.

That a level once reached immediately becomes the new normal is a related mechanism: what was an achievement yesterday is the minimum requirement today.

A perception problem comes on top. People notice their own development badly, because the yardstick moves along with them. What is easy today looks, in hindsight, as though it was never hard — and therefore never appears in the ledger. Why you usually don't notice your own progress is covered separately.

Often the situation says more than the person

The feeling usually gets treated as a trait: you either “have” it or you don't.

In fact it shows up in a strongly situation-dependent way. Three constellations are especially common:

  • In new roles. In the first months the gap between the demand and the routine is real. Reading it as a personal deficiency is understandable — and usually wrong.
  • When you are the only one of your kind in the room. Anyone who differs from everyone else in a setting objectively has fewer points of comparison. The feeling of not belonging then has a cause outside the person.
  • In fields without clear standards. Where quality can't be measured unambiguously, the feedback that could end the doubt is missing.

This shift from the person to the situation isn't only kinder. It is usually more accurate.

Why “more confidence” is the wrong advice

The standard advice is to believe in your own ability.

The problem: that belief is precisely the thing that isn't working. Being told to talk yourself into confidence hands you another task you can fail at.

Besides, confidence rarely arrives through encouragement anyway. It arrives through experience — specifically the kind of experience you can't explain away. Why self-confidence doesn't come from feeling better about yourself has its own article.

The second common piece of advice — just ignore the feeling — has a catch too: the doubt then migrates into behaviour. Overwork, endless preparation and avoiding situations where something might show are typical. When preparation becomes avoidance is described elsewhere.

What actually shifts something

Because the core is an attribution of causes, that is also where the useful moves apply.

  • Note the cause beforehand, not afterwards. Writing down what you contributed before a result lands makes it harder to reinterpret afterwards. In retrospect, the “got lucky” version almost always wins.
  • Separate competence from comfort. Something feeling uncertain says nothing about the quality of the work. The two get confused routinely.
  • The first-time rule. On a first attempt, uncertainty is the appropriate response, not a sign of fraud. The question isn't “can I do this?” but “how often have I done this before?”
  • Talk to someone one step ahead, not ten. Someone who has just cleared the same step still remembers what it felt like. Someone ten steps ahead has forgotten.

And the most effective point is also the least spectacular: saying it out loud. The pattern runs on the assumption of being the only one. That assumption rarely survives a single honest conversation.

The tone the verdict is delivered in

Closely related is the voice that formulates the doubt. It rarely sounds factual and usually sounds personal.

How to recognise that voice and what changes its status is covered in the piece on the inner critic. And when your worth hangs on output, the dynamic intensifies — see the article on worth and performance.

Why the pattern only becomes visible over time

In any single moment every doubt looks justified. There is always a concrete occasion: this task, this meeting, this piece of feedback.

Only across months does it show whether it is a pattern — and whether it is tied to particular situations, such as new roles, certain groups of people, or stretches of heavy load.

This is where Mentavo can come in: not as an assessment, but as a place where entries, mood, appointments and goals stay side by side over a longer period. In hindsight it sometimes becomes apparent that the doubt isn't evenly distributed but keeps surfacing in the same places — and that between those places lie stretches where the same person did the same work without doubting it.

What's left

The feeling of not quite belonging rarely disappears entirely. For many it stays on as a quiet companion, even after years.

What can change is how much it counts as evidence.

Because the assumption underneath — that real competence feels certain — isn't true. Certainty is usually a sign of routine, not of ability.

Someone who feels unsure is often doing something they haven't done a hundred times yet.

That isn't an indication of fraud. That is the description of something new.

Taking this further with Mentavo

Analytics: Mood, journaling, activity, goals and routines across weeks – summarised, not judged.

See “Analytics”More on Emotional Intelligence

Mentavo

Thoughts become context.

Mentavo connects what you capture about your everyday life and helps you see what truly matters today.

Download on the App Store

Newsletter

New pieces by email

When a new piece goes up, we'll send a short note. Not more often than that.

By subscribing you'll receive emails from Mentavo. You can unsubscribe at any time using the link at the end of every email. How we handle your data is set out in the privacy policy.

  • Emotional Intelligence

    5 min read

    Taking Criticism Without Taking It Personally

    The sentence isn't finished and the reaction is already there — in the body, not the mind. That is exactly what makes the usual advice useless.