Skip to content
Mentavo

Comparing Yourself to Others: Why the Comparison Almost Always Comes Out Unfair

Comparing isn't a weakness, it's a basic mechanism. The problem isn't the comparison — it's the data it runs on.

6 min read

a dark apartment window at night, the empty room faintly reflected in the glass over the lit windows of the building opposite

Someone mentions a new job. Someone else is moving. A third person posts a picture that looks very much as though everything is currently going well.

The thought that follows arrives immediately and uninvited.

“And what exactly am I doing?”

Hardly anyone likes this reflex. The usual response is to pull yourself together: don't compare, everyone has their own path, envy is unproductive.

That works about as well as deciding not to think of a pink elephant.

Comparing is not a character flaw

Comparison with other people is not a bad habit you could train out of yourself. It is one of the basic methods by which people assess themselves at all.

For most of the questions that matter in life there is no objective measure. How good someone is at their job, whether a relationship is running normally, whether you earn enough, whether you are “far enough along” at forty — none of it can be read off a thermometer.

Where an objective yardstick is missing, people take the next best one: other people.

This has been described in social psychology for decades and is considered largely unavoidable. Resolving to stop is therefore not a realistic goal.

The better question is: what exactly am I comparing against — and how good is the data?

Upwards and downwards

Comparisons run in two directions, and both have two faces.

Looking up — at someone further along — can spur you on or flatten you. What decides it is less the size of the gap than whether it looks bridgeable. Someone who believes they could reach the same thing feels stimulated. Someone who doesn't feels small.

Looking down — at someone worse off — can bring short-term relief and produce an uncomfortable feeling about it at the same time.

What's interesting is that the identical comparison can land in opposite ways for two people. It isn't the fact that decides, but the conclusion drawn from it.

Why comparison on screens is systematically unfair

Comparing has always been part of the human repertoire. What changed is not the mechanism but the material it works with.

Three things tilt the comparison when it happens through screens:

  • Asymmetric information. You see the other person's outcome and your own entire process. Their best day against your Wednesday evening.
  • Pre-selection. What gets shared has been chosen — deliberately or not. Doubts, rejections, long stretches without progress barely appear in this material.
  • A missing denominator. You see the successes of hundreds of people without seeing how many attempts they came from. That produces the impression that everyone else is moving while you are standing still.

The third point is the underrated one. People used to compare themselves with twenty others in a village. Now you see peak moments from a sample of thousands — and draw conclusions about your own life as though it were the same population.

How easily five minutes of scrolling becomes an hour is described elsewhere.

What the research says — and what it doesn't

Caution is warranted here, because few subjects attract such generous claims.

Established: there are statistical associations between heavy social network use and lower wellbeing. Also established: those associations are small on average — considerably smaller than headlines suggest.

Not established: the direction. Whether use depresses mood or depressed mood leads to more use cannot be settled from cross-sectional data. Probably both operate.

The widespread distinction between “passive” consumption, which harms, and “active” exchange, which doesn't, is also less secure than it is usually presented. Later studies could not confirm it consistently.

What can honestly be said: for some people, in some phases, with some content, the effect is noticeable. A general statement about how damaging digital comparison is isn't something the research supports.

Why people close to you hit hardest

One finding is fairly stable: comparison bites hardest where the similarity is greatest.

A billionaire's wealth leaves most people cold. A same-age colleague with a comparable background getting promoted does not.

The reason is obvious enough: only with similar people does the comparison yield usable information about your own position. Which is why comparison within your own circle hurts most — and why it helps little to tell yourself that others have it worse.

A second effect is related: the assumption that others follow your behaviour as attentively as you do. Why that is almost always an overestimate has an article of its own.

What actually helps

Not: stop comparing. That doesn't work.

What can be changed is the reference point and the quality of the data.

  • Follow the comparison through. The reflex breaks off after the first sentence. Keep asking — what exactly do I envy here, and would I be willing to pay the price for it? — and the answer is often surprisingly clear. Frequently it is no.
  • Supply the denominator. Every visible result comes with invisible attempts. That thought isn't a consolation; it is the missing half of the information.
  • Name the triggers, not the platform. “Social media” rarely sets anything off. Usually it is three or four particular people or topics. That is a much smaller and more solvable question.
  • Check the timing. The same post lands differently in the morning than at night. Tired people compare less favourably.

What comparison often conceals is the actual question: do I want this, or do I just not want to be behind? That a reached benchmark immediately becomes the new normal is a mechanism in its own right.

Comparing with yourself has a catch too

The standard advice is: compare yourself with yourself a year ago.

That is better, but not unproblematic. People are remarkably bad at noticing their own development. The yardstick moves along: what is routine today may have been difficult a year ago — and that is exactly what can no longer be recalled, because it has become normal since.

Which is why comparison with your earlier self often feels sobering as well. Why you usually don't notice your own progress is well described.

This comparison only becomes usable with a record that doesn't move along with you.

Why your own course is the better yardstick

This is where Mentavo can come in — not by judging comparisons, but by keeping your own course intact over months: what occupied you, how the mood was, what was coming up.

In hindsight that sometimes makes something visible that memory alone doesn't supply: that a question settled today was still open six months ago. It is no antidote to comparison. It is simply the one yardstick where the data is complete.

What's left

Comparison doesn't disappear. It is built in too deeply.

What can change is the quality of what gets compared — and the willingness to think the thought through rather than breaking it off at the first sting.

Because usually there is usable information in that sting. Only rarely the one you suspect first.

Taking this further with Mentavo

Discover: The Mentavo Map shows which parts of your everyday life tend to occur together – and what each recognised connection is based on.

See the Mentavo MapMore on Psychology

Mentavo

Thoughts become context.

Mentavo connects what you capture about your everyday life and helps you see what truly matters today.

Download on the App Store

Newsletter

New pieces by email

When a new piece goes up, we'll send a short note. Not more often than that.

By subscribing you'll receive emails from Mentavo. You can unsubscribe at any time using the link at the end of every email. How we handle your data is set out in the privacy policy.